PatrickPretty.com

Tag: K. Chang

  • DEVELOPING STORY: Zeek Figure Robert Craddock Accused Of Trademark Infringement And Engaging In ‘Shake-Down’ Bid Against MLM Affiliates

    EDITOR’S NOTE: The story below focuses mostly on a lawsuit filed against Zeek Rewards figure Robert Craddock by a Nevada company known as BTG180. A lawsuit filed against Craddock by a Wyoming company known as OfferHubb.net Inc. makes similar claims against Craddock.

    ** ___________________________________**

    breakingnews72DEVELOPING STORY: (4th Update 10:12 a.m. EDT Oct. 14 U.S.A.) Zeek Rewards figure Robert Craddock has been accused in a private lawsuit filed in Nevada federal court of trademark infringement and using a “shell corporation” to engage in a “shake-down” bid against affiliates of at least three MLM networks: Zeek, OfferHubb and BTG180.

    The alleged shell corporation is known as Fun Club USA Inc., according to a complaint filed Feb. 5, 2014.  It has “no employees,” was  “never capitalized” and created a condition under which Craddock was able to use funds directed to the corporation by MLMers as his personal funds, the plaintiffs contend.

    The plaintiffs in the case are listed as BTG180 LLC and Randall Jeffers. A second complaint against Craddock was filed on the same day, also in Nevada. Plaintiffs in that case are OfferHubb.net Inc. and David Flynn, who allege that Craddock “immediately” embarked on a web-based disparagement campaign against them after OfferHubb chose in July 2013 not to renew a contract with Craddock and FunClub USA.

    OfferHubb.net Inc. further accused Craddock of misrepresenting the company, breaching the OfferHubb Terms of Service by inducing affiliates to make side deals and accept kickbacks from affiliates and cross-selling other MLM opportunities in contravention of his agreement with OfferHubb.

    BTG180 is associated with a “program” known as BidsThatGive, which positioned itself as an opportunity to fight child poverty and the exploitation trades. An apparent prelaunch for BidsThatGive was conducted in July 2012, the month before the SEC moved against Zeek.

    Fun Club and Craddock are referenced in a blistering memo filed in the Zeek Ponzi- and pyramid-scheme case by the SEC on Dec. 17, 2012. In the memo, the SEC accused Craddock of encouraging Zeek affiliates “not to cooperate” with Kenneth D. Bell, the court appointed receiver. The SEC further alleged that Craddock was spreading misinformation about how the agency viewed its own case against Zeek and that Fun Club appeared to have been formed 11 days after the SEC emergency action against Zeek on Aug. 17, 2012.

    Craddock has not been charged by the SEC with wrongdoing.

    Despite the SEC’s December 2012 assertions against Craddock and Fun Club, however, BTG180 appears to have entered into a contract with Craddock and Fun Club on Aug. 12, 2013, just five days shy of the one-year anniversary of the SEC’s complaint against Zeek. In the August 2012 action, the agency accused Zeek of engaging in securities fraud, selling unregistered securities and operating a combined Ponzi and pyramid scheme that had gathered hundreds of millions of dollars in just shy of 20 months.

    BTG180, according to its own lawsuit against Craddock and Fun Club filed in February 2014, paid Craddock and the shell company $50,000 in advance of work Craddock had agreed to perform for BTG180.

    BTG180 says it wants back the $50,000 because Craddock failed to deliver. It also contends other actions by Craddock caused it to suffer damages.

    Part of Craddock’s duties, according to the complaint, was to “market the BTG180 network marketing opportunity to former affiliates of the Zeek Rewards network, which had provided products similar to those provided by BTG180.”

    Craddock did not perform the agreed-to work, according to the lawsuit. Instead, he attempted to “induce BTG180 to promote and incorporate into its product line a so-called checking account draft processing system known as BTM. Craddock is the founder of a corporation  known as BTM Check Draft Inc.”

    Without authorization from BTG180’s Jeffers, according to the complaint, Craddock pitched his BTM check system to the members of BTG180, amid false claims that it “had been approved by BTG180” and was in the company’s product stable.

    Other “confrontations” between Craddock and “BTG180 executives” ensued, and Craddock tried to “induce” BTG180 to “market other products for him,” according to the complaint.

    When Craddock “continued to defy Plaintiffs requests to stop these actions,” according to the complaint, “BTG stopped paying Craddock and Fun Club.”

    Under the terms of the contract, according to an exhibit in the case, Craddock and Fun Club were to receive $20,000 a month through BTG180, plus approved expenses, from Sept. 1, 2013 through Sept. 1, 2014.

    Craddock also was required not to reveal BTG180’s trade secrets and proprietary information, according to the exhibit.

    But at some point during contractually required Craddock visits to BTG180’s operations in Nevada, according to the complaint, BTG180 came to believe that “Craddock used a computer or several computers at BTG180’s offices to access and download and/or retain contact information of BTG180’s affiliates.”

    Craddock, according to the complaint, then sought to harm BTG180 by “disrupting and ruining its relationships with its affiliates.”

    As part of his plan to ruin BTG180, according to the complaint, Craddock established a website styled BTGlegal.com and engaged in trademark infringement while doing so. As a further part of this scheme, according to the complaint, Craddock used the website to paint Jeffers as dishonest and unethical, saying Jeffers and “other principals” of BTG180 had criminal records and a history of defrauding people.

    At the same time, according to the complaint, Craddock claimed that BTG180 had been “classified” a Ponzi scheme, that the company was to be “investigated,” that “reports” about BTG180 had been filed with the North Carolina Attorney General, that a Zeek-like action against BTG180 was planned by investigators and that “BTG180 affiliates could face criminal or other legal charges for signing up new affiliates.”

    Craddock, according to the complaint, issued an “edict” that “all BTG180 affiliates were under a cease and desist order to stop doing business with BTG180.”

    By December 2013, according to the complaint, Craddock was soliciting monthly donations of $25 each from BTG180 affiliates, saying the money would help them get back sums they had paid to BTG180. At the same time, according to the complaint, Craddock was encouraging members to contact a reporter at ABC News by email and to use a subject line that read, “They Took My Money and Used Kids to Lure me In.”

    In 2012, according to the BTG180 complaint, Craddock had solicted donations from Zeek members amid assertions he was protecting their legal interests. He eventually did the same thing to BTG180 and OfferHub participants, a “shake-down” bid targeted at MLMers, according to the complaint filed by BTG180.

    Craddock is accused in the complaint of cybersquatting, trademark infringement, wrongful use of a computer, misappropriation of trade secrets, wrongful interference with economic relations, breach of contract, unjust enrichment, defamation and hiding behind a shell company.

    The trademark-infringement claim may be particularly concerning to the MLM trade, given that Craddock has asserted he works as a copyright and trademark agent on behalf of MLM “programs.”

    On July 22, 2012, while purportedly working as a “consultant” for Zeek, Craddock filed a copyright- and trademark-infringement complaint against a HubPages website operated by Zeek critic K. Chang. K. Chang, who also posts on publications such as the PP Blog and BehindMLM.com, ultimately prevailed in the action brought by Craddock.

    Less than a month later, the SEC brought the Ponzi- and pyramid action against Zeek.

    Earlier this year, a website known as Changes Worldwide identified Craddock as its copyright agent. Filings by the SEC in June 2014 alleged that Faith Sloan, accused in April 2014 of securities fraud by the agency in its Ponzi- and pyramid complaint against the TelexFree “program,” sent more than $15,000 to an entity known as Changes Worldwide LLC after an asset freeze was opposed against Sloan in the TelexFree case.

    Sloan also was a Zeek affiliate. Whether proceeds that originated in Zeek and/or TelexFree made their way into Changes Worldwide is unclear.

    BehindMLM.com, recently the subject of a DMCA takedown notice by Sloan but now back online, reported yesterday that Changes Worldwide and a companion entity known as Changes Trading are having payment problems. As the PP Blog reported on Oct. 2, the email address Sloan used to file the complaint against BehindMLM.com was associated with a 2×2 matrix “program” known as “Diamond Holiday Feeder” that was making the HYIP rounds in 2010.

    Despite the fact Sloan accused BehindMLM.com of using on its website copyrighted material she owned, one of her 2010 promos for Diamond Holiday feeder used nearly three minutes of a soundtrack recorded in 2009 by The Black Eyed Peas to celebrate the 24th season of the Oprah Winfrey Show.

    MPB Today, a collapsed matrix cycler that led to racketeering charges in Florida against the “program” operator, is an example of a 2×2. Another example is Regenesis 2×2, which led to a U.S. Secret Service probe in Washington state in 2009. Some Zeekers are known to have promoted Regenesis 2×2.

    News broke last week that Craddock is listed on Amazon.com as the author of a book on Zeek Rewards. Marketing copy for the book asserts that the U.S. government should have modeled a “stimulus program” after Zeek, rather than shutting it down.

    In the current infringement actions against Craddock, the dockets of the case suggest Craddock no longer has paid counsel and is seeking to litigate pro se against the plaintiffs, contending that the cases should have been handled through binding arbitration, not actions in federal court.

    Craddock’s wife is a co-defendant, amid claims she and her husband used Fun Club USA to dupe MLMers who provided money to protect their legal interests.

    NOTE: Our thanks to the ASD Updates Blog.

     

     

  • Nathaniel Woods Plants Seed That Zeek Receiver Issued ‘Bogus Subpoena’ And Committed Felony; Claims Reminiscent Of Assertions Made In AdSurfDaily Ponzi Case

    UPDATED 5 P.M. ET (U.S.A.) Various members of the Florida-based AdSurfDaily 1-percent-a-day Ponzi scheme advanced various theories that judges, prosecutors and investigators committed various felonies during the course of the probe and follow-up actions in court. The claims were absurd on their face and, when the arguments were rejected, they were replaced by conspiracy theories. Time after time the conspiracy theories expanded to accommodate unpleasant fact sets, with various “defenders” of ASD retreating into an infinite set of contingencies and conflating one artificial reality after another.

    Now, a Florida resident and apparent participant in Zeek Rewards has filed a document in federal court that accuses the court-appointed receiver in the Zeek Ponzi scheme case of committing a felony. The receiver, Kenneth D. Bell, is a former federal prosecutor who once successfully prosecuted a Hezbollah terrorist cell operating in the United States.

    The PP Blog contacted the Zeek receivership today to seek comment from Bell. The Blog’s message was not immediately returned.

    In separate filings that appear on the docket of Senior U.S. District Judge Graham C. Mullen of the Western District of North Carolina, Nathaniel Woods claimed Bell or Bell’s receivership team unlawfully mailed a “bogus subpoena” to him in Ocala, Fla., thus committing a felony under Florida law.

    Mullen is presiding over the Zeek Ponzi case. In August, the SEC accused Zeek of operating a $600 million Ponzi- and pyramid scheme. Zeek’s business model was very similar to the model of ASD. ASD’s business practices triggered both civil and criminal investigations by the U.S. Secret Service in 2008.

    The subpoena, Woods claims, was meant for the purposes of “intimidation and harassment” on the part of the receiver.

    And Woods further claims that sending a “bogus subpoena” from North Carolina to Florida through the U.S. Mail constitutes “simulated process” under Florida law, a “third degree felony.”

    An accompanying document filed by Woods as an exhibit claims that “preliminary Zeek Rewards records” reviewed by the the receivership show that Woods received more than $496,000 from Zeek but paid nothing (“$0.00”) into the purported program.

    Bell is seeking the return of the money, describing it as “money lost by victims,” according to the exhibit.

    Woods is seeking to quash the subpoena, which demands records of Woods’ interactions with Zeek dating back to January 2010. He also claims the subpoena was only an “alleged subpoena” and was improperly served.

    A domain styled “500FREEBIDS4U.COM” is registered in the name of Nathaniel Woods at the Ocala street address to which the subpoena was sent, according to records. Other domains listed with an email address that appears on the registration data attributed to Nathanial Woods include Mybidshack10k.com, Mybidshackhow.info, Mybidshack4u.com and Mybidshackearn.info.

    Daryle Douglas, a onetime purported Zeek executive, also has been associated with a MyBidShack entity, according to researcher “K. Chang.”

    Zeek was a purported “penny auction” company operated by Paul R. Burks through Rex Venture Group LLC in Lexington, N.C. The penny-auction site was known as Zeekler. Zeek’s MLM arm was known as Zeek Rewards. Burks has consented to a judgment in the case. He has neither admitted nor denied the SEC’s allegations, which include securities fraud and the sale of unregistered securities.

    On Aug. 17, the U.S. Secret Service said it also was investigating Zeek. The SEC has said Burks duped investors into believing the purported Zeek “program” was paying a legitimate return of about 1.5 percent a day.

    Bell has said that perhaps 1 million people sent money to Zeek. Viewed by the number of potential victims and the number of transactions, Zeek may be the largest Ponzi scheme in U.S. history.

    Earlier this month, Bell said the receivership had gathered evidence that nearly 1 billion transactions were conducted through Zeek in about 18 months.

    AdSurfDaily was a Ponzi scheme that promoted a payout of 1 percent a day. It has about 100,000 members and gathered about $119 million, also in about 18 months, according to records.

    Records suggest that Zeek, which launched after the Secret Service brought the ASD Ponzi case, did about five times the dollar volume of ASD and potentially had 20 times the user volume.

    The civil portion of the ASD case dragged out for all or parts of five years. ASD President Andy Bowdoin admitted in May 2012 that ASD was a Ponzi scheme. In August 2012, less than two weeks after the SEC brought the Zeek case, Bowdoin was sentenced to 78 months in federal prison.

    ASD and Zeek are known to have had members in common.

  • Zeek Fallout Almost Too Strange To Contemplate

    For starters, Zeek affiliates being approached by upline sponsors and email/website appeals to send in money “to defend Zeek Rewards and all of our independent businesses as per our legal rights of due process” might want to read this July 25 PP Blog post.

    It’s about how wordplay was used to sanitize HYIP scams.

    For additional background, Zeek affiliates might want to read this July 28 PP Blog post.

    It’s about how purported Zeek “consultant” Robert Craddock sought to disable the Hub of Zeek critic “K. Chang.” Craddock now is part of the effort to raise funds to “defend” Zeek affiliates.

    Zeek and untold thousands of its minions are known to have a tin ear for PR. That tin ear is on full display again today, with a “warning” from the leaders of the effort to “defend” Zeek from the SEC’s Aug. 17 allegations that it was a $600 million Ponzi and pyramid scheme not to contact the SNR Denton law firm.

    “We have asked the firm to provide us the names of the individuals that are calling; we will refund your donation and will remove you from the group to be represented if you call. The law firm is only going to discuss the case with the 12 leaders and we will put out the information to the entire group on this site.”

    “This site,” as it were, is this site, which calls itself ZTeamBiz.

    ZTeamBiz, which calls itself a “professional organization,” says its has hired SNR Denton. The precise reason why is unclear, although ZTeamBiz says the “SEC has tried to make us all believe that Zeek Rewards was an ‘investment’ and a Ponzi scheme. All the pages that were submitted by the SEC indictment has all been one sided and what we believe to be a misrepresentation of the truth and facts of what Zeek Rewards was as a viable and legal business.”

    And ZTeamBiz also accused the SEC of misleading a federal judge.

    One of the persons on the ZTeamBiz squad — although it’s unclear if his presence is formal or informal — is Todd Disner. Disner is a former pitchman for the AdSurfDaily Ponzi scheme and, along with former attorney Dwight Owen Schweitzer, sued the government in November 2011. Disner and Schweitzer alleged that prosecutors and a U.S. Secret Service agent presented a “tissue of lies” to a federal judge when bringing the civil portion of the ASD Ponzi case in August 2008.

    Disner and Schweitzer made that claim after ASD had lost the case in U.S. District Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals. Among other things, Disner and Schweitzer claimed the government had gone shopping for a friendly judge when it brought the forfeiture proceedings.

    That judge allegedly was targeted with a false lien by Kenneth Wayne Leaming, who also targeted three federal prosecutors and a Secret Service agent with false liens, according to the FBI. Leaming was arrested by an FBI Terrorism Task Force in November 2011. He is a purported “sovereign citizen.” All five of the federal officials targeted in the alleged lien campaign have ties to the ASD case.

    ASD President Andy Bowdoin pleaded guilty seven months later to a Ponzi-related charge of wire fraud. He is scheduled to be sentenced Wednesday.

    Zeek is known to have members in common with ASD, which federal prosecutors have described as a $119 million Ponzi scheme that created at least 9,000 victims before its 2008 collapse amid allegations by the U.S. Secret Service of Ponzi fraud.

    Like Zeek, ASD claimed it was not offering an investment program. And like Zeek, ASD planted the seed it offered a daily payout rate of 1 percent a day or more.

    Like Zeek, ASD came under investigation by the U.S. Secret Service. The agency has referred to ASD as a “criminal enterprise,” with the U.S. Department of Justice calling ASD “insidious.”

    Those descriptions apparently were not enough to dissuade investors from throwing money at Zeek, which has listed ASD members as “employees.”

    On Aug, 4, Zeek itself blasted unspecified “North Carolina Credit Unions” for raising concerns about Zeek. Zeek warned members to toe the company line.

    The SEC was in federal court 13 days later.

    Zeek also is known to have members in common with JSS Tripler/JustBeenPaid, which appears now to have morphed into something called “ProfitClicking.” Both JSS/JBP and ProfitClicking may have ties to the sovereign-citizens movement.

    A domain registered in the name of purported JSS/JBP operator Frederick Mann once linked to videos featuring Francis Schaeffer Cox, a purported sovereign citizen implicated in a murder plot against public officials in Alaska.

    Because HYIP scams typically are promoted on Ponzi-scheme forums such as TalkGold and MoneyMakerGroup — and because Zeek, JSS/JBP, ProfitClicking and ASD all had a presence on those forums — questions have been raised about whether cash was circulating between and among various fraud schemes and placing U.S. banks in the position of possessing fraudulent proceeds.

    A receiver has been appointed to marshal the assets of the alleged Zeek fraud.

    Despite the appeal by ZTeamBiz for Zeek affiliates to send in money to “defend” themselves and the company, the interests of all Zeek affiliates almost certainly are not equivalent.  Net “winners” almost certainly are at risk of clawback lawsuits from the receiver. Such court actions are used to enlarge the pool through which victims of a Ponzi fraud receive a disbursement designed to make them as whole as possible.

    It’s often the case that victims never are made whole and receive disbursements of dimes or even pennies on the dollar. Such is the case to date for victims of the 2009 Trevor Cook Ponzi caper in Minnesota. That scheme was a form of affinity fraud targeted largely at people of faith, including senior citizens.

    Post-Ponzi receiverships sometimes turn into an international paper chase because scammers hide money offshore.  Reverse-engineering a Ponzi caper can take years. Even as Zeek receiver Kenneth D. Bell begins his duties, scammers on the Ponzi boards are planting the seed that the receivership cannot be trusted.

    In the 2009 Mantria/Speed of Wealth Ponzi scheme case, which in part was pushed MLM-style, a federal judge issued a specific order not to interfere with the receiver.