Federal prosecutors have revoked plea offers made during discussions with a federal public defender representing AdSurfDaily mainstay “Professor” Patrick Moriarty.
Moriarty has hired a new attorney, and prosecutors have advised the attorney that they have “voluminous” evidence, including seven 4-inch binders of records.
Part of the evidence came from records at an unspecified casino, according to court records.
“Please be advised that any plea offers previously made with the defendant’s former counsel are revoked,” said Rosemary Casey Meyers, the prosecutor handing the case, in a letter to Moriarty’s new attorney.
Meyers is an assistant U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Missouri, where a tax indictment against Moriarty was returned in March by a federal grand jury. The letter means that any offer the government might have made earlier in the case is off the table.
Other evidence, according to court filings, includes IRS records, bank records, Social Security records, business records and verbal statements by Moriarty. Some 4-inch binders hold 780 sheets of paper.
Citing his client’s poor health, Moriarty’s new attorney, Lenny Kagan, now has asked for a continuance. The government did not object. Moriarty is scheduled to have cancer surgery this month. The trial had been slotted for next month.
The prosecution agreed to let Moriarty know if it intended to introduce evidence of other crimes prior to trial, without disclosing if Moriarty was being investigated for other matters unrelated to the tax indictment handed down in March.

Moriarty was charged with filing false income-tax returns for the tax years 2002, 2003, 2004 and 2005. Prosecutors said he underreported his income by an unspecified amount for the tax year 2002; claimed a false deduction of $30,000 for “legal fees†for the tax year 2003; and claimed a false amount of $23,533 withheld for the tax year 2004 and a false amount of $23,433 withheld for the tax year 2005.
In May, the PatrickPretty.com Blog reported that Moriarty, in 2006, started a nonprofit organization for a Missouri man accused of murdering a woman in cold blood after he had shot a police officer four times.
The officer and his partner had stopped the man, Bryan Tullock, for running a stop sign in Montgomery City, Mo., on June 2, 2006. As officer Brandon LyBarger, 25, approached Tullock’s car shortly after midnight, Tullock shot him four times with a 9-mm handgun and also opened fire on LyBarger’s partner.
The second officer, Jarrod Brooks, returned fire, striking Tullock’s Cadillac but not Tullock.
When officer Brooks called for backup and went to the aid of his downed colleague, Tullock fled, police said. Tullock broke into the home of Heidi Casagrand about a block from the scene of the police shooting.
He shot and killed Casagrand, 32, and also shot at her husband. Tullock fled the second shooting scene and confronted Ricky Fry, 33. Tullock shot Fry eight times outside of his home, leaving him for dead.
LyBarger and Fry, who had been hit by a combined total of 12 bullets, survived.
Tullock was sentenced to life in prison without the opportunity for parole earlier this year. He could have been sentenced to death.
Moriarty registered the nonprofit for Tullock, the shooter, on Oct. 2, 2006, four months to the day after the rampage. Records suggest that the IRS already was interacting with Moriarty at the time be started the nonprofit.
Two years later, in October 2008, Moriarty was instrumental in registering another nonprofit in Missouri. Along with members of the Pro-AdSurfDaily Surf’s Up forum, Moriarty started an organization known as ASD Members International (ASDMI), which solicited money to do battle with the government in the civil-forfeiture case against ASD, a Florida company implicated in an alleged $100 million wire-fraud, money-laundering and Ponzi scheme.
ASDMI promised to litigate against the government even if it was behaving legally. Payments were accepted from at least 176 ASD members, but no litigation was filed.


